Jew who advocates discrimination against Muslims attacks Pink Floyd singer

The famous Pink Floyd singer, songwriter and guitarist Roger Waters has often criticized Israel’s countless war crimes against the Palestinians, and for that reason he has been attacked by powerful jewish pressure groups. One of the jews who are leading these attacks is Abraham Foxman, the (former) head of the ADL:

http://www.timesofisrael.com/adl-sadly-concludes-that-roger-waters-is-an-anti-semite/

Interestingly, Foxman advocates discrimination against Muslims, which we can read about in the following article on the jewish news site JTA:

http://www.jta.org/2014/04/23/news-...ends-choice-of-foxman-as-commencement-speaker

...and in The Daily Beast:

http://www.thedailybeast.com/articl...lizes-blanket-spying-on-american-muslims.html



I have the following questions for my fellow PF users:

Do you think that Roger Waters is an "antisemite"? Are you an "antisemite" if you criticize Israel's despicable treatment of the Palestinians?

Do you think that Abraham Foxman is a hypocrite for accusing Waters of racism against jews while he himself advocates racism/discrimination against Muslims? Or do you think that Foxman has the moral authority to call others "narrow-minded bigots"?

As always, all opinions are welcome.

 

What is this, a test of the public to absorb cognitive distortions?

All or nothing thinking, over generalizations and labeling galore.

An OP bent on useless division and Waters made it clear where he was at in his statement. Not all Jews are alike, just like Muslims and red necks.

Get over your mental conditioning.

 

This is no surprise.

Foxman and the adl create more anti-Semitism then Hitler could have ever dreamed of... FACT!

 

Waters is no anti-Semite.

Foxman seems pretty Jew hatey if you happen to be a dissenter, though.

Thankfully he's a joke human being.

 

It depends on the degree to which you criticize Jews. If you make it your life's work to criticize Jews like some of the posters on this forum, then, in my opinion, that makes you an antisemite. Sometimes there are 6 or 7 anti Jew threads on here at once. They should get a life...

 

Indeed!

 

interesting.

so you think Donald Trump and many Americans are also bigots?

they also want some form of profiling of Muslims, in order to fight terrorism

 

You know that Arabs are semites the same as Jews. The Israelis should be ashamed of the way they treat their ethnic brothers.

 

what are you supposed to do when your ethnic brother tries to kill you?

stand by and let him attack?

 

Isn't it obvious?

 

It is a rwo way street isn't it? If one looks at the situation it is clear that the Israelis intend to eventually take over all of the occupied territories. But first they have to squeeze out the people already living there. Otherwise Israel would become a real Democracy. But the Israelis don't want a real democracy. They want one that only benefits Jews.

Nothing spurs violence like oppression.

 

nothing spurs oppression like racist violence

 

That's what's so bizarre about Foxman's statements. Foxman and his ADL have attacked Trump for wanting to halt Muslim immigration into the US:

http://www.haaretz.com/opinion/.premium-1.726425

http://www.timesofisrael.com/jewish-groups-rebuff-trumps-proposal-to-ban-muslim-immigration/

So it's okay to advocate discrimination against Muslims if you're a jew (like Foxman), but wrong if you're white (like Trump)? That's the message, apparently.

 

Only one side wants to drive the other into the sea

 

Roger Waters tells the truth about jewish media control:

http://www.washingtontimes.com/news/2014/may/2/pink-floyds-roger-waters-nick-mason-rolling-stones/

Jewish religious and political leaders advocate discrimination against, and in many cases even the imprisonment and mass murder of innocent non-jews, mainly Palestinians, but also Israel's African immigrants. I'm glad to see that Waters isn't afraid to speak out against this.

 

and many Neo-Nazis want to murder the Jewish people

 

It is not a racist thing. Technically Arabs and Jews are of the same race. It is more of a religious thing. That is why the conflict will never be settled. Both sides think that their non-existent god is behind their actions. I remember once watching this show on television about the Israel/Palestinian conflict. Among the film crew was a young Palestinian man. At one point there was a group of Jews talking down Palestinians to the camera. The host of the show then presented the young man and asked what the group thought of him. They all spoke well of him, thinking that he was a Jew. Once it was revealed that he was a Palestinian the Jews turned real ugly real fast.

 

That is rather low on their agenda. Neo-Nazis especially the American kind are more about white supremacy. They seem more interested in getting rid of blacks and Mexicans. After all most Jewish people look white as the European Jews are actually mixed race - half Semite half European.

 

Roger Waters was the bass player in Pink Floyd. Dave Gilmore was/is the guitarist.

 

someday Roger Waters will understand that the Palestinians bear the brunt of the responsibility for their situation.

 

the Palestinians would have had a state years ago, if they ended terrorism

 

So they should commit mass suicide in order to please people who've been defaming and trying to kill them off and on for 1400 years? The chief problem the Palestinian have with the Jews is that the Jews won't lay down and die.

 

Many more Palestinians and Muslims want every jew dead

 

Waters has been outspoken about the the occupation for many years now, and his activism in the BDS movement. This has made him the object of criticism by various pro Zionist groups.

http://www.gilad.co.uk/writings/roger-waters-tells-the-truth-against-all-odds.html

 

The famous and goofy rabbi Shmuley Boteach, who has written books with bizarre titles like "Kosher Sex", "The Kosher Sutra" and "Kosher Adultery", attacks Roger Waters:

http://observer.com/2013/12/the-anti-semitic-stench-of-pink-floyd/

Yeah, I'm sure that means a lot coming from you, Shmuley.

Hmm…that's strange because I don't hear much about how "Neo-Nazis" are killing jews in the streets or blowing up synagogues. But let’s assume that these "Neo-Nazis" do exist: are they as influential as the jews who advocate the imprisonment and mass murder of innocent non-jews? Are they important religious and political leaders who are members of parliament or who serve in the government? (The answer is: of course not.)