You are fully aware it has not. That is why you know you cannot point to a criticism I have not refuted. I've always had a right to anyone's property that consisted of my rights. I am demonstrably right. The indisputable historical fact that slaves had the right to take their rights to liberty from their owners proves me right. <yawn> Is that what happened when abolitionists took slave owners' property from them? That has already been proved false, because it is indisputable that slaves still had a right to their liberty when their rights were property. Chanting that formula like a mantra when you know it has been comprehensively and conclusively refuted is puerile and disingenuous.