I dunno, EPV, seems like you might need to do some vetting before you give someone that much power over their fellow members. How 'bout... never been banned and have less than 3 infractions? After all, how can you trust the judgment of someone who's proved they're incapable of following the rules? Heck, I couldn't qualify under those rules... but there oughta be some kinda reward for good behavior around here. Judgeship could be like a pat on the back.