Should Israel have been created in Germany?

that's a very silly thing to believe, considering the Dutch invaded Southern Africa only a few hundred years ago.

 

Precisely

 

so you're saying that the Arabs, Assyrians, Kurds, Turks, Yemenites, Bedouin, Persians, Palestinians, Samaritans, doin't have ancestry in the Levant going back more than 300 years???

lol!!!!! talk about historical revisionism.

 

Which one is it? Which one are German Jewish ppl connected to out of those? Answer that then I'll show u how they are newcomers to the region.

 

#1. Most Ashkenazi Jews are not from Germany. They are from Poland, Russia, Ukraine, Romania, Lithuania, Belorus, Hungary.

#2. A large percentage of Ashkenazi and Sephardic Jews have the J1 haplotype, which is most common in the Levant.

#3. Most black Africans do NOT possess the J1 haplotype.



now, tell the audience your silly little fantasy about how the Palestinians, Assyrians, Arabs, Turks, Kurds, Berbers, Yeminites, Bedouin, Egyptians, Samaritans, are newcomers to the region. Base it on actual historical evidence, not Black Hebrew Israelite racist BS speculation and fairytales.

 

So which group are German Jewish ppl connected genetically lol? Turks? Syrians? Iranians?
When u can tell me who they are connected to then I can tell u the history. If u fail to do this the I have to assume u affiliate with Esau as that is the last resort for gentiles

 

sorry bro, I gave you my answer, now its your turn.

what historical evidence do you have that the Palestinians, Assyrians, Arabs, Turks, Kurds, Berbers, Yeminites, Bedouin, Egyptians, Samaritans, are newcomers to the region. Base it on actual historical evidence, not Black Hebrew Israelite racist BS speculation and fairytales.

 

still waiting for that evidence, [MENTION=56593]J0NAH[/MENTION]

 

what have Arabs, Assyrians, Kurds, Turks, Yemenites, Bedouin, Persians, Palestinians and Samaritans got to do with germans and russians in Israel?

 

now its your turn.

prove that the before mentions Levantine groups are recent migrants to the area.

- - - Updated - - -

I gave you my answer.

Now its your turn.

 

its irrelevant to the discussion unless you can prove german jewish ppl are related to a specific one of these groups.

 

I gave you my answer. Now its your turn, unless you never intended on giving your answer and are just playing childish games.

 

Here I'll give you a clue. Jewish Germans are genetically related to Turks and Greeks and Persians and Germans and Russians

 

ok, prove that the Kurds, Turks, Assyrians, Arabs, Berbers, Yemenites, Palestinians, Samaritans, are newcomers to the region.

 

none of those are Israelites

 

what evidence do you have that they are all newcomers to the region?

 

what region?

 

the region you were referring to.

listen, if you have no intention of answering and just want to play childish games, just say so.

 

Israel?

 

Folks, let's remember that the subject of this thread is whether or not a state for the Jews should have been created in Germany, as a form of justice and compensation for the Holocaust.

any/all attempts to discuss unrelated/different subject matter will be 100% ignored.

 

Adios.

 

carving a Jewish state out of a part of post WW2 Germany would have been incredible justice, for the survivors of the Holocaust.

 

Very true. And fewer would have come to Scotland too (not that that is a bad thing).